Hi @Alexander_Jones,
I’m still here and have the 9 boards that I will soon be using for my mill project, although now I will be running a Teensy 4.1 to control the ODrives via your boards.
I’ve been a little tied up with a heart op, moving and changing my main job, but back on track now.
Will let you know how I get on.
Hi @Alexander_Jones @danbowen95 @Wetmelon , I’m looking to implement the ISO7763 UART Ground Loop solution and was hoping to get some clarification/second set of eyes for the schematic necessary to use it correctly. Please see the following, any feedback is much appreciated!
Thanks,
Matt
Yep looks fine to me.
I now have this chip in and working on the breakout board above, they are awesome and brings such piece of mind when running the ODrive at higher currents.
I will make sure I get a USB isolator too, just in case I forget and plug both Teensy and ODrive into the same PC.
Here is a link to my video with it all working well: -
Thank you @Alexander_Jones 
I’m really struggling to get my isolator boards to work (Using ISO7731 chips) - although they might not be the issue. Reading voltages is not reliable (see here) and when I go to calibrate the motors via the arduino example script, the motor often does nothing, but sometimes makes a screeching sound before calibrating, but never entering closed loop control.
Couple of questions:
This is my schematic:
And this is what it looks like in real life (in amongst other components that aren’t connected)
edit: many typo’s - it’s been a long day
Looking at your setup, I would highly recommend this. 
CAN is much less hassle than Arduino in my experience. You can drive it straight from Python on a raspberry pi OR a windows or linux PC, and the ODrive CAN protocol is dead-simple.
Just one isolated CAN transciever is all you need, you can throw out the ISO7762 boards and use one of these: https://www.inno-maker.com/product/usb-can/
CAN is designed for this sort of thing and is MUCH more robust to noise than any UART.
Also, please buy some ferrite rings. 
They will help a lot.
One more point: Those brake resistors are a potential fire hazard if you mount them directly to the MDF. I would mount them on standoffs like you have done with the PCBs.
Another minor point: since you are using 24V ODrives with a 24V PSU, there’s very little headroom for the brake resistors to limit the voltage to a safe level for the ODrives. If you have an adjustment pot on your PSU, please turn it down to 22V or so. The 24V ODrives cannot handle anything above 24V.
It looks like it’s time to bite the bullet and start looking into CAN! The guide @Wetmelon has suggested previously in this thread should be a good start. I’m only looking to move 5 motors using the trapizoidal trajectory control method so hopefully it shouldn’t be too tricky.
Yes, thanks for pointing this out!
Yes, much like implementing CAN from the get go, hinesight is a wonderful thing and I absolutley should have gone with the 56v versions. I’ve turned the output voltage from the PSU to 23v.
I’m really struggling to get the system to work reliably :(.
There are no issues when moving the motors using the odrivetool, but when controlling them using the serial connection (through the teensy) the motors cut out after a short period of operation (around 5 mins). The operation consists of sending set position commands to two of the 5 motors at 25ms intervals (not going very fast or under any particularly high load).
I’m almost certain it’s a noise issue. Above is what cabinet looks like now. I’ve shielded the serial cables from the isolators and the odrive and twisted the wires from the teensy to the odrive but the problem persists.
Any suggestions on how the noise can be further reduced or any other pointers to what the problem might be? Would it perhaps help if i joined the grounds as shown below:
Really appreciate any pointers at this point!
If you can; try one odrive at a time. If that passes add another odrive to the test.
If it happens always at the same point in the teensy program may be the teensy or the program?
In my projects I use 24 volt battery packs with a 5v buck converter for my controller. I have always been suspect of bench power supplies for multiple-motor projects.
Hope something works for you!
Are you using UART Ascii or Native protocol? Which firmware are you using?
Good idea. Thinking about it systematically, the motor plugged into the top odrive (labelled 1) has never shown issues. It might be then, that the three wires coming from odrive 1 might affecting the serial wires into the odrive below, since they’re mounted so close? Similarly with odrive 2 and 3?
This means the grounds are connected (?). I’ve read that it helps to have common ground, but am scared of creating a ground loop and frying things!
Thank you for your help!
UART (I think). Here’s a snippet of code that works fine, before the motors goes into an error state
Relevant preamble:
/// Libraries
#include <HardwareSerial.h>
#include <ODriveArduino.h>
.
.
.
/// Odrive helper
template<class T> inline Print& operator <<(Print &obj, T arg) {
obj.print(arg);
return obj;
}
template<> inline Print& operator <<(Print &obj, float arg) {
obj.print(arg, 4);
return obj;
}
// ODrive objects
ODriveArduino odrive1(Serial2);
ODriveArduino odrive2(Serial3);
ODriveArduino odrive3(Serial4);
// General Machine settings
float linespeed = 20; // mm/s of linespeed
float arcspeed = 1; // mm/s of arc
float homespeed = 5; // mm/s of homing speed
float dt = 25; // how often do we send motor positions (millisecs)
void setup() {
/// Start serials
//Serial.begin(9600); // To PC (for debug)
Serial1.begin(9600); // To master controller
Serial2.begin(115200); // To odrive 1
Serial3.begin(115200); // To odrive 2
Serial4.begin(115200); // To odrive 3
}
Example function to drive two motors:
void A3A4Arc( float thetaEnd ) {
/* Move Axis 3 and 4 at an arc
*/
// Some vars
int Tmove; // How long are we running for (given dist & spd)
float A3PosFinal; // Final position of A3
float A3MotorPosFinal; // Final motor position of A3
float dA3; // Increment position of A3
float A3RevFinal; // Final A3 motor position (Revs)
float A3RevPos; // Temp pos of A3 motor as it moves (Revs)
float A4PosFinal; // Final position of A4
float A4MotorPosFinal; // Final motor position of A4
float dA4; // Increment position of A3
float A4RevFinal; // Final A4 motor position (Revs)
float A4RevPos; // Temp pos of A4 motor as it moves (Revs)
bool Done = false; // For breaking the while loop
bool Good2Move; // Can we move?
// Time
unsigned long runTime; // Current running time
unsigned long startTime; // The time we start moving
unsigned long endTime; // The time we expect to end
// For geometry
float R; // Arc radius
float theta; // floating varible
float thetaStart; // Starting value of theta
float thetaInc; // Total theta increment
float thetaRate; // Angular velo
/// Do some initial calcs
R = sqrt((A3Pos * A3Pos) + (A4Pos * A4Pos));
// theta calcs
thetaEnd = min2Rad(thetaEnd);
thetaRate = arcspeed / R; // v = wR
thetaStart = tan( A4Pos / A3Pos );
thetaInc = thetaEnd - thetaStart;
// End positions
A3PosFinal = R * cos( thetaEnd );
A4PosFinal = R * sin( thetaEnd );
A3MotorPosFinal = A3MotorPos + (A3Dir * (A3PosFinal - A3Pos) * A3Rpmm);
A4MotorPosFinal = A4MotorPos + (A4Dir * (A4PosFinal - A4Pos) * A4Rpmm);
/// Do a bunch of checks to see if we're good to go
Good2Move = axisCal( 3 ) * axisHome( 3 ) * axisCal( 4 ) * axisHome( 4 ) * withinLims( 3 , R ) * withinLims( 4 , A4PosFinal ) * withinLims( 0 , thetaEnd );
// Are we good to move it move it?
if (Good2Move) {
// I like to move it, move it
// How long will the move take, for the given speed
// Note: - linespeed should ALWAYS be a factor of 100 AND <= 100.
// (1,2,4,5,10,20,25,50,100 mm/s)
// - resolution of dist = XXX.X (mm)
// -> therefor, Tmove ALWAYS an int (millisec)
A3PosFinal = roundNum( A3PosFinal , 1 );
A4PosFinal = roundNum( A4PosFinal , 1 );
Tmove = 1000 * abs(thetaInc) / thetaRate;
// Work off time:
startTime = millis(); // The time we start moving
endTime = startTime + Tmove;
while ( !Done ) {
// calc runtime:
runTime = millis() - startTime;
// Calc change in position
theta = thetaStart + (thetaInc * (float(runTime) / float(Tmove)));
dA3 = R * ( cos(theta) - cos(thetaStart));
dA4 = R * ( sin(theta) - sin(thetaStart));
// Calc changes in motor position
A3RevPos = A3MotorPos + (A3Dir * dA3 * A3Rpmm);
A4RevPos = A4MotorPos + (A4Dir * dA4 * A4Rpmm);
// Send to position
odrive2.SetPosition(0, A3RevPos);
delay(dt);
odrive2.SetPosition(1, A4RevPos);
// If within dt of Tmax, send to final pos:
if ( runTime >= Tmove - dt) {
// Send to final position
odrive2.SetPosition(0, A3RevPos);
odrive2.SetPosition(1, A4RevPos);
// Update some values
A3MotorPos = A3MotorPosFinal;
A4MotorPos = A4MotorPosFinal;
A3Pos = A3PosFinal;
A4Pos = A4PosFinal;
// End
Done = true;
break;
}
else {
// Wait for motor to catch up and serial to clear
delay(dt);
}
}
}
}
Using the odrivetool:
fw_version_major: 0 (uint8)
fw_version_minor: 5 (uint8)
fw_version_revision: 1 (uint8)
fw_version_unreleased: 0 (uint8)
Okay, that’s UART Ascii. You are using 0.5.1, which has a stupid bug in that it sends both ASCII and Native responses, which can cause the client to stop working after a random amount of time. I suggest to update the firmware. If you want to stay on 0.5.1, I can show you which code to change to fix the firmware.
Sounds promising! It is probably easier if I update the firmware, right? I can’t think why i should need to stick with 0.5.1. I’ll update tomorrow and get back to you. Thank you!
Updated the firmware, but problems still persist. I will start a new thread as the problems seem unrelated to this. Thank you for your advise
I think you could be looking for RS485 interface. You will still be able to you whatever software using UART you already have, on both ODrive and your controller side, and RS485 will give you long, interference resistant, ground decoupled and cheap communication lines.
Something like this:
RS485 chips could be as cheap as $0.15 per piece if you buy ~dozen at once, any extra components around will be a few cents more (unless you want to go for a true high voltage isolation etc).
Software won’t even notice it’s not a plain UART anymore, you won’t need to change anything at all.
Note RS485 is a differential signal line, you don’t need to run a 3rd “ground” line in between two RS485 modules.
Edit: or you can get pre-made UART <> RS485 boards for like 50 cents each if that’s the way you prefer.
Edit: Please ignore the PSU GND shorted to a positive voltage, that was a quick sketch 
Make sure you have the ferrite rings on the motor phases. It dramatically reduces the noise.
You shouldn’t have to ground those two power supplies as shown, although I don’t think that would cause issues (since the comms lines themselves are still isolated)
