Hi. I am curious about the calculation of the power resistor.

I’m using ODrive V3.5-48V version.

I choose two Chinese hub motors from the link below for my mobile robot.

And i also see Motor guide spread sheet. but i pretty much confused about resistor concept.

Motor Specification

MAX 250W / 36V / MAX 350 RPM

During basic motor test, i’ll use battery in scooter motor battery.

**1) Power resistor Watt**

In getting started power resistor section

=> P_brake = V_emf * I_motor where V_emf = motor_rpm / motor_kv.

Kv = 350 rpm / 36v = 9.722

I_motor = 250W / 36V = 6.94A

P_brake = (RPM / KV) * I_motor = (350 rpm / 9.72) * 6.94A = 249.8 W = 250W

I use two motors. so… 250W + 250W = 500W.

Is it right to add the maximum watt of both motors?

**2) Power resistor resistance**

R = V^ 2 / P

R = 36V^ 2 / 250W = 5.184 ohms = 5ohm

it also using for two motor? 5x2 = 10ohm??

Conclusion

500W, 10ohm power resistor selected… is that right??

Does one power resistor take the capacity to handle two motor loads?

**3) Power resistor concept & safe usage**

I see other topics. (purpose & selection)

3-1) When to use a power resistor?

3-2) If my battery does not allow the brake load, it would be dangerous to use the battery. What battery parameters should I look at?

I would like to have some examples of power resistor calculations.

I now studying another topic about power resistor…

Please help!

This is what I know:

- Power resistor Watt

This is the power rating of the resistor. It tells you how much heat it can safely dissapate on a long time period. In other words, how much current you can put through it before the generated heat by Joule’s law (P = I²*R) get’s too much.

It is not correct to just add the power ratings of the motors together. This has to with how that resistor is being used (see below) and you just won’t find/need a power resistor that can dissapate that much heat. Most power resistors are 50W or 100W max.

- Power resistor resistance

10ohm is way to much. A power resistor needs to be able to put enough current through even at low voltage levels. By having that much resistance, you will limit the amount of current that can go through as a result of voltage. This is due to Ohms law (R = U/I).

I don’t know the exact procedure of calculating the resistance, but the included 0.5ohm resistor (denoted by R5) is enough for most applications and a good value to start with.

- Power resistor concepts & safe usage

A power resistor is used when the motor is braking. If the motor is braking (or therefore, coasting) it will act as a generator and generate it’s own voltage. This voltage and the currents that come with it are in reversed polarity in comparison with the voltage and currents that comes from the Odrive’s driving circuit.

If you don’t have a brake resistor to dissapate the generated electricity as heat, those voltages will be placed on the DC bus. So the voltage will rise to more than 48V.

If you are using a power supply, this is a very bad thing to have as a power supply can’t handle reversed voltages and currents.

If you are using a battery, just make sure to not cheap out on the battery. Normally a battery can handle reversed currents and voltages. But I would still recommend using a brake resistor because if your battery for some reason can’t handle it, your Odrive will jump into an overvoltage protection state to protect himself from it or if that for some reason doesn’t work, the Odrive could be permanently damaged.

2 Likes

Thank you very much. @LowiekVDS

I have a good understanding the summary of power register.

In my case, i use a battery. so, little worried about that.

just want to make it a more clearer in most cases & applications like 50W, 100W… 0.5ohm… Because If we know this, it will be very good in the future project.

I am still curious about the calculations from the motor guide documentation.

I’m going to study this a bit more and reply this post about power resistor.

Thanks!!!